Complete Clarity Solicitors

logo

Understanding the legal implications of IVF and fertility treatments in Scotland

For heterosexual couples in the UK, the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) estimates that one in seven are affected by infertility.

NICE released updated guidelines on the eligibility requirements for patients seeking fertility therapy on February 20, 2013. The recommendations mentioned same-sex couples for the first time, which is thought to represent 5% of NHS patients seeking fertility therapy. In certain cases, the recommendations also expand the qualifying standards to include women up to 42.

Modern medicine and technological advancements have made assisted reproduction a practical choice for childbearing heterosexual and same-sex couples.

As a result, NICE is keeping up with the evolving notion of modern family life.

If a child is born via IVF, who are their legal parents?

IVF/assisted reproduction in heterosexual couples

What “Mother” and “Father” mean: 

Mother: Regardless of whether she is the child’s biological mother, the woman who carried the child throughout pregnancy is recognised as the child’s mother by law.


Father: Unless he can demonstrate that he did not consent, the woman’s husband, or “consenting partner,” will be regarded as the father for all purposes if she becomes pregnant through artificial insemination, the implantation of an embryo, or the sperm or eggs inside her.

Whether or not the guy is legally considered the “father” if he is not married to the woman will depend on whether or not he was “treated together” with her and whether or not he gave written approval.

IVF/assisted reproduction and same-sex female couples

Legally speaking, female partners may be considered the parents of a child conceived through infertility therapy under the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act of 2008.

The woman who gave birth to the kid is considered the “mother” in a civil partnership or same-sex marriage, and her spouse or civil partner is considered the other “parent,” unless the other woman refuses to be considered the child’s parent.

How should the birth be registered?

Following the baby’s birth, the parents should take the documentation from the clinic to their local registry office, where the child’s birth can be officially registered, provided that the IVF/assisted reproductive treatment was performed at a licensed clinic and all required consent forms were completed there.

Should we separate, who would be entitled to our frozen eggs?

A couple must sign a contract governing the use of their embryos at the accredited clinic that will perform the therapy if they have decided to freeze their sperm, eggs, or embryos in the hopes of using them later. At that point, couples have to agree to the use of their embryos and specify how long they will be held, how they will be utilised, and what will happen if one of them passes away

Before the embryos are used, any party may, if the embryos have been frozen, withdraw their agreement at any moment.  The embryos cannot be used if it occurs. 

There isn’t much a party can do if the other party withdraws their consent if they wish to “claim” the embryos in a future divorce.  Even though it may be challenging, a person has the complete right to refuse to have their embryo utilised. In that case, the embryos will probably be destroyed as soon as consent is lost.